A growing source of silent era film information. This listing is from The Progressive Silent Film List by Carl Bennett. Copyright © 1999-2025 by Carl Bennett and the Silent Era Company. All Rights Reserved.

About This Listing Report Omissions or Errors in This Listing

Which Shall It Be?
(1924) United States of America
B&W : Five reels / 4600 feet
Directed by Renaud Hoffman

Cast: Willis Marks [John Moore], Ethel Wales [Mrs. Moore], David Torrence [Robert Moore], Paul Weigel [the musicmaster], Mary McLane, Billy Bondwin, Newton House, Miriam Ballah, Dick Winslow, Buck Black, Thayer Strain

Renaud Hoffman Productions production; distributed by W.W. Hodkinson Corporation. / Scenario by Renaud Hoffman, from the short story [?] “Not One to Spare” and/or “Which Shall It Be?”? by Ethel Lynn Beers. Cinematography by Renaud Hoffman. / © 12 June 1924 (as Not One to Spare) by Renaud Hoffman Productions [LP20300]. Released 15 June 1924. / Standard 35mm spherical 1.33:1 format.

Drama.

Survival status: Print exists.

Current rights holder: Public domain [USA].

Keywords: USA: Vermont

Listing updated: 30 October 2011.

References: Website-AFI.

Home video: DVD.